Devils And Angels: Why We Choose Our Chains

The Lovers and the Devil represent two of humanity’s most fundamental choices: love or hatred, compassion or cruelty. But why do we so often choose the very things that make us suffer? Discover how the loose chains in the Devil Tarot card reveal a profound spiritual truth about free will, the power of love, and our ability to liberate ourselves from the bondage of hatred and fear.

The Lovers card makes the bold proclamation that love is our birthright and that it flows from a divine source.

It’s right there in the card. The couple—presumably Adam and Eve—stand naked in the Garden of Eden. Eve looks upward to the angel as the source of their love, and Adam looks at Eve as the channel of that love.

OH, NO YOU DON’T!

As soon as we declare that love is our birthright and the natural order of our being, the “realists” will arrive to laugh at us.

“Look around you,” they’ll admonish us. “Do you see a lot of love happening? What about the bombings and the shootings and the genocide and the casual cruelty? How can you possibly say that love is our birthright?”

And they have a powerful point, of course. All of that IS happening in our world and has been happening for many centuries.

But coincident with that, there has been much more love than there has been horror. There is a powerful love that flows from every mother of every species to her children. There is a constant urge in the human soul to aid those who are hungry or sick or wounded. There is compassion and caring and nurturing.

Still, there’s that dichotomy in human experience. There has been great love, and there has been great cruelty.

Which do we choose? Which one do we want to live with? Which one do we want to change?

THE LOVERS AND THE DEVIL

The Devil card is inextricably linked to the Lovers. It’s the same couple. They both have a supernatural being hovering over them. They both stand naked and unprotected. But one couple is living in paradise, and the other is living in chains.

And the difference, I would argue, is one of choice: choosing to live in love rather than cruelty.

The Devil card is contained WITHIN the Lovers card. It’s the snake in the tree, right? The snake is supposed to be the Devil tempting Eve, but what is he tempting her with? He’s tempting her with choice.

The Devil is saying, “You don’t HAVE to live like this. You can CHOOSE to NOT love if that’s what you want.”

We can choose to live in love, or we can choose to live in hatred and cruelty. We are the only species on the planet that can choose to live in opposition to our basic nature.

THE CHAINS ARE LOOSE

When we look at the Devil card, one of the first things we notice is that their hands are unbound and the chains around their necks are very loose. They could, at any moment, CHOOSE to lift the chains over their heads and walk away.

But they don’t.

Now, you can flip that coin one of two ways. You can say that they’ve chosen to live in hatred and evil. Or you can say that they’ve chosen to NOT live in love.

Because the two energies can’t coexist.

You cannot be loving and compassionate AND be cruel and hateful at the same time. One energy drives out the other. Period.

This is the source of the old Buddhist adage that we don’t drive out the darkness; we bring in the light. Hatred cannot exist in the energy of love, and love cannot exist in the energy of hatred.

IS IT LOVING OR IS IT NOT?

That’s not a complicated question. With the exception of a few sociopaths and malignant narcissists, we all KNOW when we’re being kind and loving, and we KNOW when we’re being shitheads.

Put another way, for normal human beings, love makes us feel good and hatred makes us feel bad. That’s wired into us. It’s natural. It’s our birthright.

But it’s also our choice.

We can—and do—invent a million reasons for choosing to NOT be loving.

He hurt my feelings.

She looked at me wrong.

They talked about me behind my back.

Nobody understands me.

Even—Goddess help us—his skin is the wrong color.

And when we make those choices, we KNOW that they’re wrong. We know because they make us suffer, and they make other people suffer. It’s not rocket science—we know it in our hearts.

THE ANTIDOTE

Buddhism puts it in very simple terms: hatred and anger are the poison, and love is the antidote.

If you were out taking a stroll in nature and a rattlesnake bit you, would you argue with the doctor about taking the antivenin?

“Well, gosh, doc, I just don’t really know. I mean, it’s my choice, isn’t it? I’ll have to think about it and figure out what my best course of action is here.”

Meanwhile, the poison is rushing through your system, you’re getting sicker and sicker, and you may lose your leg.

We need to approach the choice between love and hatred with that same urgency.

Because the hatred is killing us.

The Devil is the poison, and the Lovers is the antidote.

Choose.

The Five of Cups: When It’s Time to Turn Our Backs on the Past

The Five of Cups is traditionally associated with grief, sorrow, and loss. But what happens when we’re grieving not just a particular event, but an entire lifetime of missed opportunities, childhood wounds, and painful experiences? This exploration of the Five of Cups examines how suffering can become part of our identity, why acceptance is essential to healing, and how turning our attention from the past toward the possibilities that remain can transform our lives. Sometimes the most important step toward happiness is simply recognizing that two cups are still standing.

One of the most familiar images in the Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot is the Five of Cups. A solitary figure stands with his head bowed, wrapped in a long black cloak, contemplating three overturned cups. Behind him, unnoticed, are two cups that remain standing. In the distance, a bridge crosses a river toward a building on the opposite shore.

Traditionally, the Five of Cups is associated with grief, disappointment, sorrow, and loss. It frequently appears in readings involving the death of a loved one, the breakup of a relationship, or some other painful experience.

The symbolism is straightforward enough. The three overturned cups represent what has been lost. The two standing cups represent what remains. The grieving figure is so absorbed in his sorrow that he cannot see the possibilities that still exist.

But I’ve been thinking about this card lately, and it occurs to me that there’s another way of looking at it.

What if the Five of Cups isn’t always about grieving something that happened recently? What if it’s about grieving the life we’ve lived?

And, more importantly, what if it’s about learning to stop grieving that life and begin living the one we still have?

The Grief We Don’t Recognize

When we think about grief, we usually associate it with a specific event. Someone dies. A marriage ends. We lose a job, a friendship, or something else that was important to us.

But there are other kinds of grief that aren’t nearly so obvious.

Consider someone who grew up in a deeply dysfunctional family. Perhaps their parents were abusive, emotionally unavailable, alcoholic, or simply incapable of providing the love and security that children need.

That child experiences some very real losses.

They may lose the opportunity to develop a healthy sense of self-worth. They may never experience the security of knowing that they are loved unconditionally. They may grow up believing that the world is dangerous, that other people cannot be trusted, or that they are somehow fundamentally unworthy of happiness.

And here’s the interesting part.

They may not even realize that they’ve lost anything.

Children generally assume that their family environment is normal. They don’t have another childhood to compare it with. If they’re repeatedly told that they’re worthless, they may simply believe it. If they’re neglected, they may conclude that their needs aren’t important.

Those beliefs can follow them into adulthood.

They may repeatedly choose dysfunctional relationships, struggle with addiction, sabotage opportunities for success, or experience a persistent sense of dissatisfaction without understanding where it comes from.

Of course, not everyone who experiences a difficult childhood develops these problems. But for those who do, the consequences can persist for decades.

And beneath those consequences, there may be an enormous amount of unrecognized grief.

Grief for the childhood they never had.

Grief for the love they never received.

Grief for the person they might have become if circumstances had been different.

In a very real sense, they may be grieving an entire life without even knowing it.

Becoming Aware of the Loss

For many people, the healing process begins with a startling realization.

Perhaps they enter therapy because they’re depressed, struggling with relationships, or experiencing problems they can’t seem to resolve.

As they begin examining their personal history, they discover something they may never have consciously recognized before.

Their childhood wasn’t normal.

The way they were treated wasn’t acceptable. And the things they believed about themselves weren’t necessarily true.

This recognition can be enormously liberating, but it can also be painful.

Suddenly, the person begins to understand just how much they lost. They may become angry at their parents or caregivers. They may feel cheated out of opportunities that other people took for granted. They may experience profound sadness over the years they spent struggling with problems that originated in circumstances beyond their control.

In other words, they begin to grieve.

And that grief is not necessarily a setback. It may be an important part of the healing process. Before we can come to terms with a loss, we generally have to recognize that the loss occurred.

In terms of the Five of Cups, we have to see the three overturned cups before we can understand what they mean.

When Grief Becomes an Identity

Everyone experiences grief differently.

Some people recover from painful experiences relatively quickly. Others require months or years. There is no universal timetable, and the length of someone’s grieving process is not a measure of their character or emotional strength.

But there’s another possibility worth considering.

Sometimes grief becomes so deeply incorporated into our sense of self that it begins to define who we are.

Spiritual teacher Eckhart Tolle has written extensively about the way people construct identities around their suffering.

There’s a significant difference between saying, “I experienced something terrible,” and saying, “I am a person whose life was ruined by something terrible.”

In the first statement, suffering is something that happened to us. In the second, suffering has become part of our identity.

And once that happens, moving beyond the suffering can become surprisingly difficult.

We may become so accustomed to seeing ourselves as victims of our circumstances that we unconsciously continue to interpret our experiences through that identity.

Every disappointment becomes further evidence that life has treated us unfairly. Every failed relationship confirms our belief that we’re unlovable. Every setback reinforces the conviction that happiness is something other people experience.

The original suffering was real. The injustice may have been enormous.

But the identity we’ve constructed around that suffering can sometimes perpetuate its influence long after the original circumstances have ended.

And this brings us back to the Five of Cups.

Look at the figure in the illustration. He’s completely enveloped in his black cloak. We cannot see his face or identify much of anything about him.

For the moment, grief appears to be his entire identity.

He is not simply someone who has experienced a loss. He has become the grieving figure.

The Healing Process

Recognizing the origins of our suffering is an important beginning, but recognition alone doesn’t necessarily resolve it.

There may be years of conditioning to unravel.

We may need to examine beliefs about ourselves that were formed in childhood. We may have to recognize destructive patterns in our relationships. We may need to learn how to establish boundaries, trust other people, or experience emotions that we learned to suppress.

And we may have to grieve.

Not just for the original childhood experiences, but for the consequences that followed us into adulthood.

Perhaps we spent twenty years in an unhappy marriage because we never learned what a healthy relationship looked like.

Perhaps we abandoned opportunities because we believed we weren’t capable of succeeding.

Perhaps we spent much of our lives trying to win the approval of people who were incapable of giving it.

These realizations can be painful. And there’s no reason to pretend otherwise.

But at some point, another question begins to emerge. How long do we want to continue standing in front of those three overturned cups?

That’s not a question about how long someone should grieve. Nor does it suggest that grief can simply be switched off through an act of will.

It’s a question about the direction of our attention and, ultimately, the direction of our lives. Because while we’re examining everything that went wrong in the past, something else is happening.

Our present life is continuing. And the future is approaching.

Acceptance: The Moment We Turn Around

I think one of the most important elements in recovering from grief is acceptance.

And by acceptance, I don’t mean approval.

We don’t have to decide that the things that happened to us were acceptable. We don’t have to forgive people who hurt us. We don’t have to convince ourselves that our suffering was somehow necessary or that everything happened for a reason.

We can look back at our childhood and say, “That was terrible. It shouldn’t have happened. I deserved better.”

All of those things may be absolutely true. But there’s another truth that eventually has to be acknowledged.

It happened. And nothing we do today can change the fact that it happened.

We cannot go back and have a different childhood.

We cannot recover the years we spent in unhappy relationships.

We cannot undo the mistakes we made because we didn’t understand the forces influencing our behavior.

We can learn from those experiences. We can heal many of their consequences. We can change the way they influence our present lives. But we cannot change the past itself.

And perhaps that’s the turning point represented by the Five of Cups.

The grieving figure finally recognizes that the wine spilled from those three cups is not going to flow back into them. No amount of sorrow, anger, regret, or resentment will make that happen.

The loss is real. The past is over. And there are still two cups standing.

The Two Cups That Remain

Here’s something I find particularly beautiful about the symbolism of this card.

The figure doesn’t have to create the two remaining cups. They’re already there.

He doesn’t have to earn them. He doesn’t have to repair the three overturned cups before he’s allowed to enjoy them. He simply has to turn around and recognize their existence.

And what might those two cups represent?

Perhaps they represent the capacity to love and be loved.

Perhaps they represent creativity, friendship, curiosity, pleasure, or the ability to find meaning in ordinary experiences.

Perhaps they represent opportunities that we haven’t yet recognized because we’ve been so preoccupied with what went wrong.

Or perhaps they represent something even more fundamental. The realization that we are more than the sum of the things that happened to us.

Our childhood may have shaped us, but it doesn’t have to define every aspect of our future. Our losses may have changed us, but they don’t have to become our entire identity.

And the years we’ve already lived, however painful they may have been, don’t have to determine how we experience the years that remain.

Of course, turning around doesn’t mean that the grief magically disappears. We may continue to feel sadness about the past. We may occasionally find ourselves looking back at those overturned cups. Some losses may always hurt.

That’s part of being human.

But there’s an enormous difference between remembering our suffering and organizing our entire lives around it.

We can acknowledge what we’ve lost while also embracing what remains. In fact, doing so may be an essential part of healing.

The Bridge to the Future

There’s one final detail in the Five of Cups that deserves our attention.

In the background of the Rider-Waite-Smith illustration is a bridge leading across a river toward a building on the opposite shore.

The grieving figure has his back to that bridge. He’s so absorbed in contemplating the overturned cups that he cannot see the way forward.

And perhaps that’s the ultimate message of the card. The bridge doesn’t lead backward. It cannot take us into the past and give us the childhood we deserved, the marriage we wanted, or the opportunities we missed.

It leads toward something that hasn’t happened yet.

Our future.

And we don’t have to wait until every trace of grief has disappeared before we begin crossing it. We can carry our memories with us. We can acknowledge our wounds. We can continue healing as we move forward.

But first, we have to turn around.

What Does the Five of Cups Want?

In traditional Tarot readings, the Five of Cups is often interpreted as a warning against becoming so absorbed in loss that we overlook what remains.

I think that’s a perfectly valid interpretation. But I also think the card has something much more profound to tell us.

Sometimes the three overturned cups represent a particular disappointment or tragedy. And sometimes they represent an entire personal history of suffering, deprivation, and regret.

Either way, the message is essentially the same. We cannot change what has already happened.

We can recognize it. We can grieve it. We can learn from it. And, in time, we may come to accept it.

But eventually, if we want to experience the possibilities that still exist, we have to redirect our attention toward the life that remains available to us.

The Five of Cups doesn’t ask us to deny our suffering. It doesn’t ask us to pretend that the past was different. And it doesn’t demand that we finish grieving according to someone else’s timetable.

It simply reminds us that our losses are not the entirety of our lives.

Three cups have fallen.

Two are still standing.

And there’s a bridge waiting to be crossed.

At some point, we have to decide whether we’re going to spend the rest of our lives contemplating what we’ve lost—or begin discovering what we still have.

NEW FREE TAROT EBOOK: WHAT THE TAROT CARDS WANT

Announcing What the Tarot Cards Want: Unlocking the Hidden Energies of the Tarot, a free illustrated ebook exploring all 78 Tarot cards from a fresh perspective. Discover what each card’s energy wants to express, what may be blocking it, and how to work with that energy through practical affirmations. Download your free copy today!

I’m delighted to announce the publication of my newest Tarot book, What the Tarot Cards Want: Unlocking the Hidden Energies of the Tarot.

And the best part? It’s absolutely free!

This illustrated book takes a different approach to understanding the Tarot.

Most of us approach a Tarot reading by asking what the cards mean or what they’re predicting about our future.

But what if we asked a different question?

What do the cards WANT?

The premise is simple: Each of the 78 Tarot cards represents a unique type of energy that’s trying to express itself in our lives.

The Magician wants us to recognize our abilities and put them to work. The Ace of Cups wants us to open our hearts to love and emotional connection. The Eight of Wands wants us to embrace movement and momentum.

But sometimes those energies are blocked by our fears, beliefs, habits, or circumstances.

That’s where this book comes in.

Each of the 78 illustrated card definitions explores three questions:

* What does the card want? What energy is trying to express itself?

* What blocks it? What might be preventing that energy from manifesting?

* How can we work with it? Each card includes affirmations designed to help us consciously align with its energy.

The result is a practical Tarot reference guide that shifts the emphasis from predicting the future to actively participating in creating it.

I’ve included an original illustration for every card, along with a clickable table of contents so you can quickly find the definitions you’re looking for.

I’m offering the book as a free karma gift to the Tarot community. No registration, no email address, and no strings attached.

Discover What the Tarot Cards Want and Download Your Free Copy

DOWNLOAD HERE

I hope you enjoy it, and that it gives you a fresh perspective on those 78 remarkable little pieces of cardboard.

Happy reading!

Daniel Adair

The World – The Dance of Life

The World marks the completion of the Tarot’s great journey—but every ending contains a new beginning. Explore the card’s mysterious wands, its connection to The Fool and The Magician, and the symbolism of dance, rebirth, integration, and divine play.

As the final card of the Major Arcana, The World is both the end of a cycle and the beginning of a new one.

Yes, we’ve come to the end of the long journey through the archetypes. The lessons have been learned, the trials endured, and the pieces brought together. But Tarot doesn’t really have an ending. The moment one journey is completed, another begins.

The World isn’t a period.

It’s a doorway.

THE WREATH — COMPLETION AND REBIRTH

The most obvious symbol of completion is the enormous wreath surrounding the central figure.

But look at its peculiar shape. Rather than being perfectly circular, the wreath forms a long oval. It can easily suggest an opening, a portal—and perhaps even the shape of the birth canal.

Seen that way, the figure isn’t simply standing triumphantly inside a wreath celebrating what she has accomplished. She’s passing through it. She’s arriving at the destination and simultaneously being born into another world.

That’s one of the great paradoxes of The World: completion and beginning are the same event. Every genuine transformation eventually requires us to leave behind the person who began the journey.

THE FOOL, THE WORLD, AND THE DANCE OF LIFE

At the very beginning of the Tarot journey we encountered The Fool.

He’s filled with such exuberance that he practically dances toward the edge of a cliff. He doesn’t know where he’s going. He hasn’t experienced the Magician, the Lovers, Death, the Devil, the Tower, the Moon or any of the other archetypal encounters awaiting him.

He simply steps forward.

Now look at the figure in The World.

She’s dancing, too. But this is a very different dance. The Fool dances because he doesn’t yet know what lies ahead. The World dances because she does.

She has traveled through the entire cycle and somehow recovered the joyous freedom with which she began it.

This idea has a fascinating parallel in Hindu philosophy.

Shiva as Nataraja—the Lord of the Dance—is portrayed dancing within a great circle of flame. His dance represents the ceaseless movement of existence: creation, preservation, destruction and renewal.

The visual resemblance to The World is striking: a dancing figure surrounded by a circular boundary representing something vastly larger than the individual.

Hindu traditions also give us the wonderful concept of līlā, usually translated as “divine play.” Līlā suggests that creation doesn’t necessarily arise because the divine lacks something or needs to accomplish some desperately important objective. Creation can be understood as spontaneous expression—something closer to art, music, play or dance.

An artist paints. A musician plays. A dancer dances. Creation creates.

This doesn’t mean that suffering is unreal or that life should never be taken seriously. It suggests something subtler: beneath all our struggling, planning and attempts to control events, there may be another way of participating in existence.

We can dance with it.

The woman in The World is being born into something new, but she isn’t grimacing with effort. She’s having a hell of a lot of fun doing it.

THE MAGICIAN, THE WORLD, AND INTEGRATION

There’s another fascinating connection between The World and one of the earliest cards in the Major Arcana.

The woman holds two peculiar short, double-ended wands loosely in her hands. We’ve seen that wand before. The Magician holds one.

But notice the difference in how the two figures use them.

The Magician raises his wand deliberately toward heaven while pointing his other hand toward Earth. His entire posture communicates intention:

I will make something happen.

He channels divine power into manifestation. He gathers the four elemental tools before him and consciously directs his will.

The World no longer needs to do that. She holds two wands, perfectly balanced on either side of her body. She isn’t pointing them anywhere. She isn’t commanding anything. She almost seems to be playing with them.

They’ve become part of the dance.

The Magician uses magic. The World embodies it.

At the beginning of the journey, we have to learn that we possess creative power. We have to discover intention, will, concentration and the ability to shape our lives. But perhaps there comes a point when even that must be surrendered.

The Magician says: I am creating my world.

The World says: I am the creation.

The World Tarot Poster – Available on etsy

THE MAGIC CIRCLE

Now notice the four mysterious figures occupying the corners of the card: the human or angel, eagle, bull and lion.

They have a long symbolic history extending far beyond Tarot, but within the Tarot’s esoteric correspondences they can be associated with the four fixed signs of the zodiac:

Aquarius — Air

Scorpio — Water

Taurus — Earth

Leo — Fire

Once again, all four elements are present. We encountered them on the Magician’s table at the beginning of the journey. Now they surround The World.

This gives the card an almost ritual quality. In Western ceremonial magic, the four directions and their elemental correspondences can be invoked around a ritual space. Symbolically, then, we can imagine the dancing woman standing within a great magic circle surrounded by the forces of creation.

But something has fundamentally changed.

The Magician stood before the elements and manipulated their symbols. The World dances among them.

Mind, emotion, body and spirit are no longer competing forces that need to be brought under control. They have become parts of a larger whole. That is integration.

And perhaps that’s what The World ultimately means by completion. Not perfection. Not reaching a place where nothing difficult will ever happen again.

Wholeness.

WHEN THE WORLD APPEARS IN YOUR READING

When The World appears in a reading, something has come full circle.

A long process may be reaching completion. You may finally understand something that once confused you, finish something you’ve worked toward for a long time, or realize that you’ve simply outgrown a particular chapter of your life.

But don’t mistake completion for stagnation. The World almost always contains the seed of what comes next.

You may be standing at exactly that strange threshold where you can look backward and say, “I’ve finished,” while simultaneously looking forward and realizing, “Now I begin again.”

The card can also indicate integration. Pieces of yourself that once seemed contradictory may finally be learning to coexist. The intellectual, emotional, physical and spiritual parts of your life may be finding their proper relationship with one another.

And sometimes The World offers an even simpler message:

Stop trying so hard to control the dance.

You’ve learned more than you realize. You have the tools. You’ve survived the journey.

Now loosen your grip on the wands.

Listen for the music.

And dance.

The Judgement Card and Starting a New Cycle

Judgement card,Judgement tarot card,Judgement in a tarot reading,Judgement card definition, Judgement card meaning, tarot major arcana, self judgement, the judgement card and reincarnation,Judgement Day,gabriel angel, tarot lesson, tarot blog, tarot books

There’s something creepy about the Judgement card, especially to the modern eye. When we see corpses climbing out of coffins, our minds immediately go to some sort of a zombie apocalypse where dead people are trying to take over the earth.

Yikes! Run away, run away!

JUDGEMENT AND REINCARNATION

Obviously, the intent of the card and the artist was to portray Judgement Day, when the Angel Gabriel blows his horn and we all rise from the dead and have a nice brunch with Jesus and his Daddy.

While that may seem like a bit of a primitive belief today, it probably points toward the doctrine of reincarnation. We have to remember that the Tarot was introduced into Europe at a time when the Inquisition was in full swing. The priests and monks would happily tie you to a stake, light a fire under you, and toast s’mores if you deviated from their doctrine.

Reincarnation definitely deviated from their doctrine, so the designers of the Tarot cards had to have a way to introduce the concept without getting themselves killed. Judgement Day was the closest Christian analog to the concept, and so we have this very Christian scene with reanimated corpses.

JUDGEMENT AND THE TAROT JOURNEY

The Major Arcana of the Tarot shows the journey of the new soul, as illustrated in The Fool, through the various stages of life here on the Earth School. At different times we may reincarnate as royalty, as warriors, as mystics, as priests and prelates, each lifetime a stage of growth and evolution.

Included in those cards is the Death card. Now, the logical question here is why the Judgement card wasn’t paired with the Death card. That would be the normal Christian sequence, would it not? You live your life, you die, and then Gabriel blows his horn and you pop into heaven or hell. Period.

Using the Christian doctrine, Death and Judgement should have been the last cards in the deck. But they aren’t.

The Death card is followed by eight other cards, indicating that mortal death is far from the end. It isn’t even the end of that one journey; it’s just a rest stop.

The Judgement card reminds us that the journey goes on. When one lifetime ends, another begins, and we continue to reincarnate again and again until we finally learn the lessons we’re here to learn.

THE SYMBOLS

The symbolism in the Judgement card is a little heavy-handed.

The coffins represent past restrictions or boundaries that we’ve overcome.

The group of people rising from the coffins—man, woman, child—shows people rising from those restrictions and moving beyond them.

The angel blowing the horn denotes the divine vibration that reanimates us in our new incarnation.

For the most part, I discard the cross on the flag as another sop to Christian theology. If it were simply a white flag, we could interpret that as purification and starting over.

The mountains show the new obstacles that we’ll have to overcome in the next incarnation.

WHEN YOU GET JUDGEMENT IN A READING

Judgement obviously indicates a major awakening in our life. When it turns up in a reading, it shows that we’ve made a judgement about our lives and we’re turning in a whole new direction.

It is NOT about being judged by some cranky old man in the sky.

Ultimately, Judgement is about self-judgement. It’s taking stock of our lives and deciding whether we’re satisfied with what we’ve been doing. It’s making a decision about what direction we move in next. In most cases, if the card is upright, it indicates that we’ve made a positive judgement—we can look back over our incarnation and feel that we’ve made the right decisions and we’ve evolved. Now it’s time to move onward.

If the card is reversed, it can indicate harsh, negative self-judgement. It can indicate that we’re clinging to the past, refusing to move forward and deal with the karma we’ve accumulated. We choose to stay in our little boxes rather than starting a new cycle.

And, having made those judgements, we move on to the last card in the Tarot cycle, the new lifetime, The World.

THE SUN — JOY WITHOUT EFFORT

The Sun represents far more than happiness and success. Through the mysterious symbolism of the child, white horse, enormous red banner, stone wall, and radiant sun, the card reveals a deeper state of being—innocence without naïveté, power without force, balance without control, and joy that arises naturally when we finally stop struggling against ourselves.

The Sun is one of the most immediately joyful cards in the Tarot.

Everything about it seems to announce happiness. A brilliant sun fills the sky. Sunflowers rise above a stone wall. A white horse moves peacefully through the scene, carrying a laughing child who waves an enormous red banner.

Traditionally, The Sun is associated with happiness, vitality, success, clarity, and optimism. All of those meanings are perfectly valid. But they don’t really explain the picture.

Why is the central figure a naked child? Why is the child riding without reins? Why does Pamela Colman Smith give this tiny figure a banner far larger than any child could reasonably carry? And why is a stone wall standing in the middle of this otherwise exuberant landscape?

Perhaps Smith is showing us something much more profound than happiness.

Perhaps The Sun depicts what happens when we finally stop struggling against ourselves.

THE CHILD WHO COMES AT THE END OF THE JOURNEY

It is tempting to look at the child in The Sun and think immediately of the modern concept of the inner child. There is certainly some resonance there, but the placement of The Sun within the Major Arcana suggests something deeper.

This child appears very late in the Tarot journey. We have already passed through The Devil, confronted The Tower, stood naked beneath The Star, and traveled through the strange nocturnal landscape of The Moon.

This is therefore not the innocence of someone who has never encountered darkness. It is innocence recovered after encountering it.

That distinction is important.

The Fool is innocent because the journey has barely begun. The figure in The Sun has traveled through nearly the entire Major Arcana.

This is not naïveté. It is simplicity on the other side of complexity.

The child can therefore be understood as something closer to the ancient archetype of the Divine Child: something newly born within us that appears small and vulnerable while possessing extraordinary power.

The personality has not returned to childhood. It has rediscovered something child-like.

Naturalness.

Spontaneity.

Trust.

Wonder.

Joy.

NAKED IN THE SUNLIGHT

The child’s nudity reinforces the idea.

There is nothing to hide.

Throughout the Tarot, people wear costumes that tell us who they are. Kings have crowns. Priests have robes. Warriors wear armor. The Emperor sits dressed in the symbols of authority.

The child in The Sun has none of them. No rank. No profession. No armor. No social identity.

Nothing stands between the child and the world.

This is especially striking after The Moon.

Under moonlight, appearances become uncertain. A rope can look like a snake. The familiar becomes strange. Material rises from the unconscious in dreams, fears, fantasies, intuitions, and projections.

The Sun changes the light.

Nothing needs to remain hidden because everything can now be seen clearly. And the figure who emerges into that illumination has nothing left to conceal.

WHO IS RIDING WHOM?

Then there is the horse.

At first glance, we naturally say that the child is riding it.

But look again.

There are no reins. The child isn’t gripping the horse with her legs. In fact, her legs kick exuberantly outward. She isn’t clutching the mane or concentrating on maintaining control. She appears almost unconcerned with the mechanics of riding.

Perhaps the child isn’t controlling the horse at all. Perhaps the horse is carrying the child.

That gives us an entirely different image of power.

The horse can represent the animal nature—the body, instinct, appetite, physical energy, and all those parts of ourselves that conscious thought so often tries to control.

The Sun offers another possibility.

The child doesn’t dominate instinct. She trusts it. Horse and rider are in balance without visible control.

There is no struggle between the conscious and instinctive self because they are no longer trying to go in different directions.

POWER WITHOUT FORCE

This brings The Sun surprisingly close to the Taoist concept of wu wei—often translated as effortless action or action without forcing.

The child accomplishes everything without apparent effort.

And nowhere is that more obvious than in the enormous red banner. Look at its size. It is absurdly large.

The artist understood human proportions perfectly well. A child that size should struggle even to keep such a large flag upright, particularly while sitting unsecured on a moving horse.

Instead, the child casually holds it aloft with one hand while it billows dramatically across the sky.  This tiny figure possesses outsized power.

But there is no evidence of effort. No straining muscles. No grim determination. No attempt to demonstrate strength.

The child doesn’t act powerful. She simply is.

Perhaps this is one of the central mysteries of The Sun: The Sun is not the power of forcing things to happen. It is the power that becomes available when we stop fighting ourselves.

THE RED BANNER

The banner itself deserves attention.

Its brilliant red is almost discordant against the yellows, whites, blues, and grays dominating the rest of the card. It demands to be noticed.

Red is the color of blood, heat, passion, vitality, and physical existence. It is the color of life.

And the child doesn’t hide that vitality. She raises it above her head and lets it unfurl across the sky.

The gesture is almost declarative.  I am here.

After the uncertainty and ambiguity of The Moon, there is no hesitation about existence in The Sun. Life announces itself.

THE WALL

And then we come to that peculiar stone wall.

Why place a wall in this scene at all?

Walls divide. They establish boundaries between what is inside and what is outside, what is permitted and what is excluded, what is protected and what is kept away.

Behind the wall are the sunflowers.  In front of it are the child and horse.

Something has crossed a boundary. She has simply emerged beyond it.

We might think of that wall as all the things that have separated us from our natural selves: conditioning, fear, social expectations, defensive structures, old beliefs, and identities we once needed but eventually outgrew.

The Sun doesn’t necessarily destroy them.  It illuminates them and moves beyond them.

THE FLOWERS THAT SEEK THE LIGHT

Behind the wall are four enormous sunflowers. Their symbolism could hardly be more appropriate.

Sunflowers turn toward the light. They suggest the natural movement of life toward illumination—not because someone commands it, but because that is simply what the organism does.

And perhaps that is another clue to the entire card.  Nothing in The Sun seems to be trying very hard.

The sun shines because that is its nature.

The flowers turn toward it because that is their nature.

The horse carries the child because horse and rider are moving together.

The banner flies because the wind catches it.

And the child rejoices because joy has become natural.

Everything is doing what it does without struggling to become something else.

JOY WITHOUT A REASON

This also helps explain the extraordinary joy of The Sun.

We often think of happiness as something caused by circumstances.

We will be happy when we get the job. When we find the relationship. When the money arrives. When the problem disappears.

But nothing identifiable has happened to make this child happy. There is no treasure chest. No victorious army. No palace. No admiring crowd.

She is simply alive beneath the Sun. Her joy seems to arise from being completely at home in herself.

That may be why the card feels so different from ordinary images of success.

The child isn’t celebrating an achievement.

She is celebrating existence.

WHEN THE SUN APPEARS IN YOUR READING

The Sun can certainly indicate the traditional qualities associated with it: happiness, success, vitality, confidence, clarity, and favorable circumstances.

But on a deeper level, it may ask a more interesting question:

What would happen if you stopped fighting yourself?

Perhaps you don’t need another layer of control. Perhaps you don’t need more armor. Perhaps you don’t need to force the horse to go where it already knows how to go.

The Sun can appear when something authentic is ready to emerge from behind the walls that have contained it.

It encourages trust in your own nature. It asks you to allow yourself to be seen.

And it reminds you that genuine power does not always announce itself through effort, dominance, or control.

Sometimes power looks like a tiny naked child carrying an impossibly enormous banner while a horse gently carries her into the sunlight.

She is small without being weak. She is vulnerable without being afraid. She is powerful without exerting force. She is balanced without needing control.

And she is joyful without needing a reason.

That is the illumination of The Sun.

THE MOON — DON’T MISTAKE MOONLIGHT FOR DAYLIGHT

The Moon is traditionally associated with illusion, uncertainty, and blurred reality—but why? By exploring the card’s dreaming face, open gateways, howling dog and wolf, and the strange creature rising from the water, we uncover a deeper meaning: The Moon represents those moments when subconscious fears, desires, memories, and intuitions begin coloring our perception of reality. The road is still there—we’re simply seeing it by moonlight.

The Moon is traditionally one of the more unsettling cards in the Tarot.

Illusion. Confusion. Deception. Uncertainty. Blurred reality. Things are not quite what they seem.

Those are perfectly good definitions, but they leave us with a question: Why? Why does the Tarot choose this particular collection of images to represent those ideas?

There is a pool of water with a strange crustacean crawling out of it. A dog and a wolf howl at the Moon. A road passes between two towers and winds away through an empty landscape. Strange drops of energy fall from the sky.

And above everything hangs an enormous Moon containing a human face.

Perhaps the key to understanding the entire card is right there.

The Moon’s eyes are closed.

THE DREAMING MOON

Look carefully at the Moon’s face. It isn’t screaming or displaying terror. It appears troubled, perhaps even melancholy, but its eyes remain firmly closed.

Nighttime. Moonlight. Closed eyes.

The Moon is dreaming. And perhaps it isn’t experiencing a nightmare so much as a troubled dream—the kind in which uncomfortable material from somewhere below consciousness begins working its way toward the surface.

That gives us a very different way of approaching the card.

During ordinary waking consciousness, we maintain a reasonably firm distinction between the world outside us and the world inside us. We distinguish memories from present events, imagination from observation, fears from facts.

Dreaming changes all of that.

The boundaries become porous. Memories mingle with fantasies. Fears become characters. Emotions become landscapes. People who died twenty years ago walk through the front door. Places we’ve never visited somehow feel completely familiar.

The subconscious speaks—but it speaks in its own peculiar language. And while we’re dreaming, we generally accept all of this as reality.

THE GATES ARE WIDE OPEN

The two towers in The Moon are usually interpreted as something we must pass through on our journey along the road.

But suppose we’ve been traveling in the wrong direction.

There is no obvious destination at the distant end of the road. The Tarot frequently used radiant light and other visual devices to suggest a glorious destination or spiritual attainment.

There is nothing like that here.

So what happens if we reverse direction?

Suppose we are traveling toward the pool rather than away from it.

Suddenly the towers become an entrance. And there’s something peculiar about that entrance: It’s wide open. The towers are separated by a broad expanse of land. There is no wall connecting them. No gate. No guardhouse. No barrier.

Nothing prevents us from entering.

That makes wonderful psychological sense if the landscape represents a dream—or, more broadly, a state in which the subconscious is becoming unusually active.

The gates between conscious and subconscious experience are open.

THE DOG AND THE WOLF

Just inside those gates we encounter two closely related animals: a dog and a wolf.

The wolf represents the primitive animal—the creature governed by instinct. The dog is essentially that same creature after thousands of years of domestication. It has learned the rules. It has adapted itself to human civilization.

Psychologically, the pairing is almost irresistible.

The wolf can represent our primal self: instinct, appetite, fear, aggression and everything else civilization has taught us to restrain. The dog can represent our conditioned self—perhaps even the ego attempting to maintain order.

And what does a guard dog do when something approaches the boundary?

It barks.

Both animals are howling at the Moon.  The intruder is the subconscious material and that’s what the wolf and dog are trying to keep out.

The ego may try to keep the contents of the subconscious at bay, but under the influence of The Moon, it cannot maintain complete control.

SOMETHING IS COMING OUT OF THE WATER

Then we reach the pool.

Water has long been associated with the subconscious and emotional realms, and the Tarot places it prominently at the bottom of the card.

And something is crawling out of it.

The strange crayfish or lobsterlike creature appears almost prehistoric. It belongs to a much older world than either the dog or wolf.

If the pool represents the subconscious, this creature can represent something equally ancient within ourselves: primitive psychological material that predates our carefully constructed conscious identity.

And it is rising.

The Moon, of course, controls the tides. The Tarot imagery therefore gives us a marvelous metaphor: the Moon is drawing something out of the depths.  Out of our depths.

Something normally submerged is coming to the surface.

That may be a forgotten memory. An instinct. A fear. A desire. An intuition. An old emotional wound. A creative image. Something we know without knowing how we know it.

The important point is that it has crossed—or is crossing—the boundary into consciousness.

WHAT IS A “MOON-LIKE” STATE?

This is where the symbolism becomes much broader than ordinary dreaming.

We might think of The Moon as depicting any Moon-like condition in which ordinary conscious control is weakened and subconscious material begins exerting an unusually powerful influence over our perception.

Dreaming is the most obvious example, but it isn’t the only one.

Intense anxiety can create a Moon-like state. So can grief, infatuation, obsession, fantasy, emotional overwhelm, trance, intense creativity and other experiences in which our interior world becomes unusually powerful.

And that’s when perception becomes tricky. Because we aren’t necessarily hallucinating something that doesn’t exist. More often, we’re interpreting something real through the light of our subconscious mind.

THE ROPE AND THE SNAKE

Imagine walking outside at night and seeing something long and curved lying across the path.

In daylight, you would immediately recognize it as a rope. But under uncertain moonlight, it looks remarkably like a snake. Your heart pounds. Your body tenses. You stop walking.

The rope is real.

The darkness is real.

Your fear is certainly real.

The snake isn’t.

Your subconscious has taken incomplete sensory information and supplied the rest.

That is The Moon.

And we do precisely the same thing psychologically.

An employer sends an email saying, “Could you come see me this afternoon?” If you’re already worried about losing your job, your subconscious may immediately finish the story. I’m getting fired.

Someone you love seems unusually quiet. They’re angry with me.

A new romantic interest doesn’t answer a message. They’re losing interest.

In each case, something actually happened. But subconscious fear, desire or expectation supplied information we didn’t possess.

The feeling may be real. The interpretation may not be.

BUT SOMETIMES THE SNAKE REALLY IS A SNAKE

And this is where The Moon becomes more interesting than a simple warning against illusion.

The subconscious isn’t necessarily wrong. Sometimes what we call intuition may be the subconscious assembling information the conscious mind hasn’t yet recognized.

Perhaps that quiet person really is angry. Perhaps something actually is wrong at work.

Perhaps some tiny combination of expression, tone of voice and behavior has registered below conscious awareness and produced the unmistakable feeling that something isn’t right.

That is why intuition belongs to The Moon just as surely as illusion does.

The problem is that under moonlight it can be extraordinarily difficult to distinguish between them.

Is this intuition—or fear? Am I perceiving something—or projecting something? Do I know this—or merely feel it very strongly?

The Moon doesn’t necessarily answer those questions.

It tells us that we need to ask them.

WHEN THE MOON APPEARS IN A READING

When The Moon appears, we don’t necessarily need to assume that somebody is lying to us or that everything around us is an illusion. Instead, the card may be telling us that subconscious material is strongly coloring our perception of the situation.

Something may be rising from the depths that deserves our attention. But this probably isn’t the moment to accept every fear, intuition, fantasy or suspicion as objective fact.

Ask yourself:

What do I actually know?

What am I assuming?

What am I afraid might be true?

What do I want to be true?

Is an old experience influencing how I interpret the present one?

Could my intuition be noticing something my conscious mind hasn’t recognized yet?

And perhaps most importantly:

Do I have enough light to see this clearly yet?

Sometimes we simply have to wait until we can see more clearly.

The lesson of The Moon may not be that we should distrust everything we experience in darkness. Dreams, emotions, instincts and intuitions can contain profound truths.

But they speak the symbolic language of the subconscious, and that language shouldn’t always be taken literally.

A rope may look like a snake.

A fear may masquerade as intuition.

And intuition may arrive disguised as an irrational fear.

The road is still there.

We simply have to remember that we’re seeing it by moonlight.

The Star and Shining Bright in Our Lives

The Star Card as the reborn self.

To paraphrase a wonderful movie:

“What does a star do? It shines.”

And that is precisely what The Star in the Tarot portrays: our ability to shine our light into the world around us.

Through a Jungian lens, the Tarot can be read as a visual map of individuation—the lifelong process of bringing the conscious and unconscious parts of ourselves into a more complete and integrated whole.

The Star represents an important moment in that journey. Something inside us has come together. Mind, spirit, emotion, and instinct are no longer fighting one another quite so fiercely. We have begun to understand who we are.

And now we’re ready to share it.

The Star isn’t searching for her light. She is the light.

THE STAR AND THE TOWER

The Star appears immediately after The Tower. There is no coincidence in that sequence.

As we recently discussed, The Tower can depict not merely the destruction of circumstances in our outer world, but the collapse of the psychological structures we have built around ourselves.

The Tower takes everything false, everything unsustainable, everything inauthentic—and burns it right to the ground.

But inherent in that destruction is the possibility of rebirth. When there is nothing left, we have to start over. And when we start over, we have the opportunity to rebuild our lives on something more authentic.

To quote the old Kris Kristofferson line made famous by Janis Joplin:

“Freedom’s just another word for nothing left to lose.”

That is precisely where The Star enters the story. The Tower has stripped away the false structure. The crown has fallen. The walls have collapsed. The old identity has been shattered.

And yet—we’re still here.

Perhaps for the first time, we are free to become something closer to our authentic self.

The Tower says: This is what you are not. The Star answers: Then let me show you what you are.

THE STAR AND THE HERMIT

Another way to understand The Star is to compare her with The Hermit, because in some respects they represent almost opposite energies.

Psychologically, The Hermit represents deliberate introversion. He steps away from the collective noise of society to enter the inner world alone. He is searching for something that cannot be found amid the chatter and expectations of everyone around him.

Visually, his heavy gray cloak creates a boundary between himself and the world. He stands alone on his snowy mountain peak, carrying only his staff and lantern. The lantern represents consciousness illuminating the darkness—the small light with which he explores the unknown territories within himself.

The Hermit isn’t simply alone.

He wants to be alone.

He isn’t trying to share something. He’s trying to find something.

The Star is different.

She has emerged from that inward journey. She stands naked beneath the stars, without armor, cloak, crown, fortress, or disguise. There is nothing separating her from the world around her.

She isn’t searching for another source of energy. She has become a source.

She pours her water—her energy, creativity, compassion, wisdom, and essential self—back into the world.

Some goes into the pool, the realm of emotion and the unconscious. Some goes onto the earth, nourishing ordinary life.

She isn’t hiding. She’s nourishing. And perhaps most importantly, she isn’t diminished by giving. Her vessels don’t seem to run dry.

That is one of the profound lessons of The Star: when what we give comes from the authentic self rather than from obligation, fear, or the desperate need for approval, sharing ourselves does not necessarily empty us.

Sometimes it makes us more fully ourselves.

The Star Poster – 13 X 19 Inches – Available on Etsy

THE GUIDING STAR

Jung used the ancient term psychopomp for an archetypal figure that mediates between different realms of experience—particularly between consciousness and the unconscious.  The psychopomp is a guide who leads us from one realm into the next.

The Star can be understood as such a guide.  She is leading us from the destruction of The Tower into our own light.

But whatever psychological language we use, the message of The Star is remarkably simple.

We are meant to shine.

We are supposed to shine.

And for many people, that is much more difficult than it sounds.

Psychologist Brené Brown has described shame as the intensely painful experience of believing that we are flawed and therefore unworthy of love, belonging, and connection.

That belief can become one of the most powerful forces keeping us from fully participating in our own lives. We don’t show people what we’ve created because perhaps it isn’t good enough.

We don’t speak because perhaps what we have to say isn’t important.

We don’t pursue the thing we desperately want because perhaps we aren’t talented enough, attractive enough, intelligent enough, young enough, educated enough—or simply enough.

So we hide.

We become smaller. We cover ourselves in the Hermit’s cloak long after the period of solitude has served its purpose.

The Star has moved beyond that shame.

Look at her. She is completely exposed beneath an enormous night sky, yet there is nothing defensive about her.

She isn’t comparing herself with the other stars. She isn’t wondering whether Sirius is brighter. She isn’t asking whether someone else deserves to shine more than she does.

She simply shines.

And by doing so, she becomes a guide for everyone still standing in the darkness.

She seems to be saying: This is how you do it.

This is how you shine.

WHEN THE STAR SHOWS UP IN YOUR READING

When The Star appears in a reading, it often signals healing, renewal, authenticity, and the return of hope after a difficult period.

But I think its message goes considerably deeper than simply, “Things are going to get better.”

The Star asks you to stop hiding.

If you’ve recently experienced your own Tower—a loss, upheaval, disappointment, failure, or profound change—The Star suggests that the destruction may have cleared away something that was preventing you from becoming more completely yourself.

The question now is not simply: How do I get my old life back?

The better question may be: Who am I now that the old life is gone?

The Star can also appear when you have something that needs to be shared.

An idea. A talent. A piece of art. A book. A truth. A kindness.

A way of seeing the world that belongs uniquely to you.

You may still hear the old voice whispering that nobody wants it, that somebody else could do it better, or that you have no business putting yourself forward.

The Star says otherwise.

She doesn’t promise applause. She doesn’t promise success. She doesn’t even promise that everyone will understand what you have to offer.

She simply reminds you that your light cannot illuminate anything while you are hiding it.

So when The Star appears, ask yourself:

Where am I still making myself smaller than I need to be?

What part of myself am I finally ready to reveal?

What do I have that could nourish someone else?

And perhaps the most important question of all:

What would happen if I simply gave myself permission to shine?

Because what does a star do?

It shines.

The Devil and the Problem of Unconscious Choice

The Devil Card and the need for choice before morality.

One of the most frequently discussed details in the Rider-Waite-Smith Devil card is the chains.

The naked man and woman stand chained to the black pedestal beneath the Devil, but a closer look reveals something peculiar. Their hands are completely free, and the chains around their necks are so loose that either figure could simply lift the loop over his or her head and walk away.

That gives us one of the standard interpretations of The Devil: we are often imprisoned by things that we can walk away from if we choose to do it.

It’s a powerful interpretation, and one I’ve discussed before. (See my previous post The Devil Card and Freedom.) But it raises another question that may take us deeper into the card.

What if the people don’t know that they can take the chains off?

Why Don’t They Take Off the Chains?

When we look at the picture, knowing that the chains are loose, their behavior seems completely puzzling.

Why don’t they simply leave?

One answer might be that they just don’t want to.  They might actually be enjoying whatever’s keeping them in chains.  Maybe they like getting drunk.  Maybe they’re having a really hot secret affair with their next door neighbor and it feels mighty fine.  Maybe they like being an addict.

But when we look carefully at the card, it doesn’t look like they’re making any kind of conscious decision at all.

Look at them.

They aren’t struggling against their chains.

They aren’t examining them.

They aren’t looking toward one another for help.

Most strikingly, neither of them is looking at the Devil.

There is an enormous, gigantic, scary, horny creature looming immediately behind them, and they seem almost completely unaware of his presence.

The man is even more remarkable. The Devil holds a flaming torch downward toward him, and the man’s tail has caught fire.

He doesn’t seem to notice.  Really?  Wouldn’t you notice it if your tail caught fire?  I know I would.

But maybe we’ve been asking the wrong question.

Instead of asking “Why don’t they choose to remove the chains?” perhaps we should be asking:

“Do they realize they’re wearing chains at all?”

Do they even realize that they’re slaves?

The Devil We Don’t See

This gives us a very different way of understanding the card.

The Devil represents something we haven’t yet seen.

We could make a serious case for the idea that most of us don’t make conscious choices about our lives.  Oh, we think we do and we like to brag about how well informed we are, but do we really?

There are, of course, marvelous exceptions but most of us are born in a particular rut and stay in that rut for most of our lives.  If we were born into a Christian family, we’ll probably stay Christians.  If our parents always voted Republican, we’ll probably vote Republican.  If we were born middle class, we’ll probably die middle class.  

We can say the same thing about our habitual ways of thinking.  If our parents were cynics and viewed the world skeptically, we will, too.  If our parents were depressive or angry, we’ll probably be depressed or angry, too.  If we were raised in a racist family, we’ll most likely be racist adults.

By the time we reach adolescence, we are thoroughly programmed little robots.  We may get a nose ring or a tattoo and call it rebellion, but soon enough we return to the rut we were born in.

And all the while, WE HAVE NO IDEA that we’re not making our own choices.  In fact, a part of the programming we receive is that we have freedom of choice when we really don’t.

It might be a belief inherited from our parents. It might be an assumption about money, sexuality, success, relationships, gender, class, religion or respectability. It might be a fear acquired in childhood. It might simply be a habit repeated for so many years that we’ve forgotten there was ever another way of behaving.

We don’t say, “I have chosen this.”

We say, “That’s just the way things are.”

And that may be one of the most powerful chains of all.

Morality Requires Choice

This brings us to perhaps the most provocative aspect of The Devil.

We traditionally associate the Devil with immorality. But what if the deeper problem depicted by the card is not immoral choice at all?

What if it is the absence of conscious choice?

In Jung and Tarot: An Archetypal Journey, Sallie Nichols writes:

“Without freedom to choose, there can be no true morality. The fact is that most of us today have more free choice than we realize; but many, still unconsciously imprisoned within cultural mores, refuse to accept the responsibility for moral choice.”

That distinction is crucial.

Morality isn’t simply obedience to a collection of rules. Genuine morality requires the ability to recognize alternatives, understand consequences, and then choose among them.

If I behave in a particular way merely because “that’s what people do,” I haven’t necessarily made a moral decision.

If I follow a religious commandment without ever examining it, I may be obedient—but obedience and morality aren’t the same thing.

If I repeat the prejudices of my culture because I’ve never recognized them as prejudices, I haven’t consciously decided that they are right.

And if I hurt another person while blindly acting out an unconscious fear or compulsion, the consequences remain real even though I may never have consciously intended them.

Consciousness creates the possibility of moral choice.

That’s where The Devil becomes considerably more complicated than a card about temptation or sin.

The people beneath him may not be wicked.

They may simply be asleep.

The First Act of Freedom Is Seeing the Chain

That brings us back to the apparent paradox at the center of the picture.

The couple are free. And they aren’t free.

Objectively, nothing prevents them from lifting those chains from their necks. Subjectively, however, they may have no idea that such a possibility exists.

Freedom therefore requires something before choice. It requires awareness.

We have to see the chain. We have to recognize the Devil standing behind us.

We may even have to notice that our tail is on fire.

Only then can we decide what we’re going to do about it.

Perhaps that is why The Devil occupies such an important place in the Major Arcana. He confronts us not simply with our appetites or our bad behavior, but with the uncomfortable possibility that forces we haven’t recognized may be making some of our choices for us.

The moment we see those forces clearly, something changes. We may still choose to remain exactly where we are.  But now it really is a choice.

What The Devil Means in a Reading

When The Devil appears in a reading, then, the question may not simply be “What has you trapped?”

A more useful question might be:

“What are you taking for granted that you have never consciously chosen?”

Look for the invisible assumption behind the situation. A relationship pattern, an inherited belief, a fear, a social expectation, a desire, an old family rule, or simply the conviction that “I don’t have any other choice.”

The card doesn’t necessarily tell you to break the chain.

It asks you first to see it.

Because once the chain becomes visible, you can finally decide whether to keep wearing it.

Temperance: Finding the Right Proportion

The Temperance card as a personal balancing act.

Temperance is usually defined as moderation, balance, and avoiding extremes. But the imagery of the Tarot suggests something more precise. Temperance is not simply about having less of something—it is about discovering the right proportion between different forces in our lives.

At first glance, Temperance can seem like one of the simpler cards in the Major Arcana. An angel stands quietly, pouring liquid from one cup into another. One foot rests on the earth while the other stands in water. Behind the angel, a path winds toward distant mountains and a brilliant golden light.

Nothing particularly dramatic is happening.

But perhaps that’s the point.

Temperance is about the delicate process of bringing different parts of ourselves—and different parts of our lives—into the proper relationship with one another.

Temperance as a Cardinal Virtue

Temperance is one of the traditional cardinal virtues, along with Justice, Fortitude and Prudence. Three of these virtues survive quite recognizably in the standard Tarot: Justice, Strength (Fortitude), and Temperance. Prudence is conspicuously absent. (For more on the missing Prudence card, see my previous post Dear Prudence – The Mysterious Case of the Missing Tarot Card.)

In older Tarot decks such as the Tarot de Marseille, the imagery of Temperance is considerably simpler than that of the Waite-Smith card. We generally see an angelic figure pouring liquid between two vessels.

To modern eyes, pouring something from one cup to another may not immediately suggest moderation. Historically, however, the connection was much more obvious.

The older meaning of temperance was not merely abstaining from excess. The Latin root temperare carries the sense of regulating, combining or mixing things in the correct proportions. Water and wine, for example, could be mixed so that the strength of the wine was tempered.

This gives us the fundamental symbolism of the two cups.

Temperance is creating the right mixture.

And importantly, the right mixture does not necessarily mean equal amounts.

Balance Doesn’t Always Mean 50/50

We often visualize balance as equality. Put the same amount on both sides of a scale and equilibrium is achieved.

Temperance offers a different model.

Suppose you’re making soup. Equal quantities of salt and water would certainly represent equality, but they wouldn’t produce anything you’d want to eat.

The ingredients have to be present in the proper proportions.

The same principle applies to life.

We need work and rest, but that doesn’t mean twelve hours of each every day. We need independence and connection, reason and emotion, discipline and spontaneity. What constitutes the right balance changes according to circumstances.

Temperance therefore represents something more sophisticated than simply avoiding extremes. It asks:

What does this particular mixture require?

That is a dynamic form of balance. The liquid in the card is moving because maintaining equilibrium often requires continual adjustment.

Temperance Poster – 13 X 19 – Available on Etsy

One Foot in the Water, One on the Land

A. E. Waite and Pamela Colman Smith greatly expanded the symbolism of the older Tarot image.

One of their most famous additions is the angel’s peculiar stance: one foot rests on dry land while the other is immersed in water.

Water traditionally represents emotion, intuition, imagination and the unconscious. Solid ground suggests physical reality, stability, practicality and the tangible world.

The angel doesn’t choose between them.

It participates in both.

We could read this very simply as advice to feel deeply without losing our grounding.

Someone who lives entirely through emotion may be swept along by every changing feeling. Someone who insists upon remaining completely rational and controlled may become disconnected from intuition and emotional reality.

Temperance asks for neither extreme.

It asks us to discover the useful proportion between them.

Head and Heart

Something similar appears in the symbols placed upon the angel’s forehead and chest.

It’s entirely possible that these were meant to represent the influences of the heart and brow chakras. And their placement naturally suggests another important polarity.

Head and heart.

Thought and feeling.

Reason and intuition.

Again, the card does not tell us which should win.

Imagine someone deciding whether to remain in a difficult relationship. Their emotions may say one thing while the observable facts say another.

Temperance doesn’t necessarily say, “Ignore your feelings and be rational.”

Nor does it say, “Follow your heart regardless of the evidence.”

Instead it asks the person to bring both sources of information into the same vessel.

What do I feel?

What do I know?

And what conclusion emerges when both are given their proper weight?

That’s Temperance at work.

Justice Weighs; Temperance Blends

This also gives us an interesting distinction between two of the cardinal virtue cards.

Both Justice and Temperance concern balance, but they achieve it differently.

Justice balances by weighing.

Temperance balances by blending.

Justice holds a scale. Separate things are compared against one another until equilibrium is established.

Temperance pours one thing into another. The elements aren’t merely compared—they become part of a new mixture.

That makes Temperance particularly useful when apparently contradictory needs are both legitimate.

Perhaps someone is pursuing an important creative project but becoming exhausted.

The answer isn’t necessarily to abandon the project. Nor is it necessarily to push harder.

Temperance asks a different question:

What proportion of work and restoration will allow the work to continue?

Perhaps the problem isn’t the goal at all.

The mixture is wrong.

The Path Toward the Light

Behind the angel is another important feature: a winding path disappearing into the distance.

It eventually reaches mountains beneath a brilliant golden light, within which appears something resembling a crown.

This introduces movement into an otherwise remarkably still card.

The angel isn’t walking along the road. The angel stands quietly performing the work of integration.

The road comes afterward.

That suggests a beautiful practical interpretation of Temperance. Sometimes we cannot see how to move forward because something within our present situation is badly out of proportion.

We may be working too much and recovering too little.

Thinking endlessly and feeling too little.

Giving constantly and receiving nothing.

Dreaming without acting—or acting without considering where we’re going.

When those elements are brought back into a workable relationship, the next step may become much easier to see.

The balance isn’t the destination.

The balance makes the journey possible.

Temperance in a Tarot Reading

When Temperance appears in a reading, the familiar advice to practice moderation is perfectly valid—but we can make it considerably more useful.

Temperance may be saying:

Something here needs to be brought into better proportion.

That might mean less of something, but it could equally mean more of something that has been neglected.

Too much work may require rest. Too much caution may require a little risk. Excessive emotional involvement may need perspective. Excessive intellectualization may need feeling. Constant giving may need to be balanced by receiving.

The card can also suggest that two things we’ve been treating as opposites don’t actually require an either/or decision. Perhaps they can be combined.

And that brings us back to those two cups.

The angel continually pours between them, adjusting the mixture.

Temperance isn’t asking us to eliminate one part of ourselves in favor of another. It asks us to discover how the different parts belong together.

Find the right proportion. Integrate the opposites. And when the mixture is right, continue along the path.