What Should You Do When a Tarot Reading Makes No Sense?

What do you do when a Tarot reading makes absolutely no sense? Before assuming the cards have failed, consider what they may be reflecting. Mental confusion, rapid life changes, hidden information, or simple denial can all produce a seemingly muddled reading. Learn how to recognize underlying patterns, step back from confusing cards, and trust that sometimes the best answer is simply: more will be revealed.

There are times, especially when you’re new to reading Tarot cards, when you lay out a reading and it makes absolutely no sense. Not only does it seem to have nothing to do with what’s happening in your life, but the cards don’t even seem to connect with each other.

So what do you do when that happens?

I’ve found that a good first step is to step back, look at the cards, scratch your head, and say: “What in the HELL does that mean?”

It doesn’t solve the reading, but it clears the air.

There are, however, some questions we can ask that may help.

HOW’S YOUR HEAD?

I’ve found that I’m most likely to get muddled readings when I’M muddled.

In other words, it’s not the cards’ energy. It’s my energy.

After all, when we lay out a Tarot reading, it’s a snapshot of what’s happening in our lives at that particular moment. It may tell us something about what’s happened in the immediate past, what’s going on right now, and what’s likely to happen in the immediate future.

If I’ve got a head full of fuzz because I haven’t been taking care of myself energetically, that’s exactly what’s going to show up in the reading. If I’m anxious or a bit hyper, if my thoughts are bouncing all over the place like a pinball, the reading may bounce all over the place, too.

Feed Your Head – Available on Etsy

It isn’t that the cards AREN’T working—it’s that they are. They’re mirroring back to me exactly what my current reality looks like. If my thoughts don’t make any sense, neither will the reading.

ARE THINGS CHANGING IN YOUR LIFE?

There are times in everyone’s life when things change very rapidly.

We can be plodding along, getting up in the morning, going to work, doing our jobs. Life is perfectly normal.

Then suddenly we feel as if we’ve been thrown into a blender.

Perhaps we come home from work and discover that our partner has moved out. Perhaps we’re suddenly transferred to a new office and have to move. Perhaps we wake up one morning and think, “Man, none of this makes any sense. I’m starting over.”

When our lives are in flux, our readings may be in flux, too.

If things are changing so rapidly that we can’t keep up with them, the cards may simply be reflecting that reality. When things begin to settle down, the readings often will, too.

IS THERE A LOT OF RATIONALIZATION OR DENIAL GOING ON?

This can apply when we’re doing readings for ourselves, but it can be particularly important when we’re reading for other people.

It’s perfectly natural for all of us to try to present ourselves in the most positive light. Sometimes, however, we take that to the extreme of completely denying what’s really going on in our lives.

You may sit down to do a reading for someone who appears to have it all together. They’re well dressed. They’ve got a good job, a loving partner, and 2.5 beautiful children.

That’s what they’re projecting to the world—and perhaps to themselves. But underneath the image of the perfect life, they’re a mess. Their partner is emotionally abusive, their children are having trouble in school, their credit cards are maxed out, and they’re behind on their house payments.

So you lay out the cards. The reading reflects all of that.

And they look at you and say, “That’s not right. Everything in my life is wonderful.”

The cards may be telling the truth, but the questioner isn’t.

SO WHAT DO WE DO?

The solutions to all of these scenarios are fairly straightforward.

1. Wait and do the reading again later. If you’re extremely upset, physically exhausted, very anxious, or mentally scattered, you’re probably not going to get a clear reading.

Get some rest. Meditate. Do some EFT tapping. Clear your energy.

When you’re clearer, your reading may be clearer, too.

2. Accept the chaos until it settles down.

If everything in your life is upside down and sideways, you’re probably not going to get a nice, orderly reading.

If you don’t know what the hell is going on in your life, why should the cards pretend otherwise?

Once things begin to settle, your readings may begin to make more sense.

3. Remember that the cards may actually be one hundred percent accurate—but there are factors you aren’t aware of.

If the questioner is lying to you, withholding information, or simply unable to see what’s happening in their own life, a reading may LOOK as if it doesn’t make sense when it actually does.  And if we’re lying to ourselves, we may genuinely be unable to see the patterns in our lives, even when they’re laid out in front of us.

The missing ingredient may simply be information.

LOOK FOR UNDERLYING PATTERNS

Another thing we can do with a muddled reading is stop trying to interpret every individual card and look at the reading as a whole.

Are nearly all of the cards reversed? That may indicate that much of what’s happening is internal, blocked, delayed, or being experienced subjectively rather than expressed openly in the world.

Is one suit predominating?

If you get a reading that’s almost entirely Cups, emotion and relationships may be overwhelming everything else.

If Swords dominate, there may be too much thinking, worrying, conflict, analysis, or mental agitation.

Too many Wands may indicate that you’re pushing too hard, trying to do too much, or running on nervous energy and sheer willpower.

And if Pentacles dominate, you may be overly focused on money, work, security, possessions, or the practical realities of life.

You don’t necessarily have to understand every card to understand what the reading is telling you.

WHAT ABOUT THE MAJOR ARCANA?

Are there a lot of Major Arcana cards?

This can be an especially important clue when your life has gone topsy-turvy. Any card from the Major Arcana can act like a bright, flashing light saying:

“Pay attention. This is important.”

If you have several Major Arcana cards in a single reading, you may be dealing with something larger than the ordinary events of the day. Major forces may be at work in your life. An old pattern may be ending. A new phase may be beginning. Something fundamental may be shifting.

And if that shift is still underway, it may be impossible to see exactly where it’s taking you.

BE PATIENT

There’s a saying in 12-Step groups: More will be revealed.

And that’s often true with the Tarot.

If a reading doesn’t seem to make any sense, wait a few days and look at it again. If it still doesn’t make sense, set it aside and come back to it later.

Very often you’ll discover that the cards were astonishingly accurate. There was simply a piece of the puzzle you didn’t have yet. As a little time goes by, the missing pieces emerge—and suddenly the reading makes sense.

If you’re a beginner, I’d actually encourage you to keep a Tarot journal.

Write down your readings—especially the ones that make no sense—and then go back and check them after a few days or a few weeks.

I think you’ll be surprised at what you find.

Can You Read Tarot for Yourself?

Can you read Tarot cards for yourself? Absolutely—but self-readings come with both advantages and pitfalls. Learn why reading Tarot for yourself can be remarkably insightful, how personal blind spots can affect your interpretations, and why repeatedly asking the cards the same question usually creates more confusion than clarity.

A question that many newly minted Tarot readers ask is, “Can I do readings for myself?”

And the answer to that is: Oh, hell, yes.

People have been doing Tarot readings for themselves for as long as people have been reading Tarot cards.

It’s not an unreasonable question, though. In all the years I’ve been doing Tarot readings, I’ve heard the same statement from several people:

“You can’t do readings for yourself. Everyone knows that.”

I’ve never been able to track down exactly who “everyone” is, or where they came up with this rule, but the idea is definitely out there.

So, just to be definitive about it: it’s wrong.

The Advantages of Reading for Yourself

The most obvious advantage of reading for yourself is that nobody knows you quite like you know yourself.

And that means there’s often much less guesswork involved in figuring out what the cards mean.

For instance, suppose a card like The Devil comes up in your reading. Someone who doesn’t know you can make a series of educated guesses based on the traditional meanings of the card.

“Ummm . . . there could be a problem with addiction in your life. Or perhaps there’s an unhealthy or obsessive sexual element involved. Or you might be refusing to recognize some pattern of self-harm . . .”

But they don’t really know, because they don’t really know you.

You, on the other hand, can look at the same card and immediately realize:

“Yeah, I’m drinking too much.”

Or:

“I really shouldn’t be having an affair with the neighbor’s wife.”

Or:

“I really need to quit sticking pins in that voodoo doll of my boss.”

That simple self-knowledge can make a reading much easier and clearer than one you might get from a stranger. You already know the cast of characters, the circumstances, and the history. The card doesn’t have to explain the whole situation to you. It only has to point at it.

The Disadvantages of Reading for Yourself

The major disadvantage of reading for yourself is that—guess what?—we’re all human.

We rationalize. We deny. We conveniently overlook things. And many of us have a somewhat inflated—or at least carefully edited—image of ourselves.

Sometimes we can look at cards that are giving us a very, very clear message and simply say:

“Nope. That’s not me.”

Psychologist Jennifer Freyd coined the term “betrayal blindness” to describe the way people can sometimes remain unaware of betrayal when recognizing it would threaten an important relationship or situation.

To use an extreme example, someone might be married to an absolute cheating horn dog—a partner who is screwing around with other women all week long and twice on Sunday—but she simply cannot allow herself to see it.

She finds the motel receipts, the lipstick on the collar, and the condoms in the glove box, but somehow there’s a perfectly reasonable explanation for all of it.

That same person probably isn’t going to see the truth in the Tarot cards either.

She might lay out a reading that practically screams that her partner is a no-good, lying, cheating lowlife, and she’ll still find some way to interpret the cards differently.

And we all have areas of our lives where we deceive ourselves.

For most of us they aren’t quite that dramatic, but the blind spots are still there. Someone else reading for us may spot those inconsistencies immediately, while we unconsciously find ways to explain them away.

That’s the real danger of reading for yourself. It isn’t that the cards somehow stop working when you’re the person shuffling them.

It’s that you may not want to hear what they’re saying.

Don’t Obsess

There’s one other warning about reading for yourself that’s worth mentioning:

Don’t obsess.

In other words, don’t fall into the pattern of constantly reading the cards, looking for one more clue about what you’re supposed to do.

And that’s tempting. Believe me.

After all, when you’re reading for yourself, the readings are free and you can do as many of them as you want.

But realistically, Tarot readings tend to fall into two broad categories.

The first kind is crystal clear. It tells you, in effect:

“This is what’s happening. This is what you need to do. And this is probably what will happen if you don’t do it.”

The second kind—which is much less common—is muddled. The cards don’t seem to form a coherent message, or several contradictory possibilities seem to be in play.

In my experience, that usually means the situation itself hasn’t settled yet. Too many things are moving around, and you simply need to wait until the dust clears.

Either way, doing another seventeen readings probably isn’t going to help.

If you’ve already received a clear reading, the answer isn’t going to change just because you keep asking the question.

And if the reading is genuinely muddled, it probably isn’t going to become clear until the situation itself becomes clearer.

All you’re likely to get from repeatedly throwing the cards is frustration, confusion, and a big fat waste of your time.

Keep Reading

So, by all means, read Tarot for yourself.

Just be reasonable about it, and remember that self-knowledge cuts both ways. Knowing your own life intimately can make a reading extraordinarily clear—but your own biases and blind spots can occasionally make the obvious invisible.

Unless there’s a specific problem I need to address, I usually do one predictive reading at the beginning of each week. It gives me a general feel for the energies and circumstances I’m likely to encounter.

It’s a simple four-card reading:

1 — What are the current conditions?
2 — What needs to be done?
3 — What factors are working against me?
4 — What is the probable outcome?

And that’s it.

That gives me all the information I need to stumble through the week.

Sometimes the reading surprises me. Sometimes it tells me something I already suspected. And sometimes I don’t fully understand what a card was talking about until several days later.

But the point isn’t to consult the Tarot every fifteen minutes.

The point is to get the message, think about it, and then go live your life.

Why Do I Keep Getting the Same Tarot Card Over and Over?

Why does the same Tarot card keep appearing in your readings? A repeating card may point to stuck energy, an important person in your life, or something you haven’t been willing to see. Learn why Tarot sometimes repeats itself—and what that persistent card may be asking you to notice.

One of the spookier things that can happen to a new Tarot reader is getting the same card over and over again.

No matter how many readings you do, there it is. It may drift around to different positions in the spread. It may appear as an answer to completely different questions. You shuffle thoroughly, cut the deck, and perhaps even put the cards away for a few days.

And then you do another reading. There it is again.

It can begin to feel as though the card is glued to your aura.

Oddly enough, this can also be one of the most reassuring experiences in Tarot. There are 78 cards in a standard deck, so when one particular card begins appearing with remarkable persistence, it certainly gets your attention.

So what does it mean?

In my experience, there are three basic reasons a Tarot card may keep appearing:

1. Stuck energy — something in your life isn’t changing.

2. A particular person — someone important is being represented by the card.

3. Something you aren’t acknowledging — an important situation or energy needs your attention.

STUCK ENERGY

A Tarot reading doesn’t really “predict the future.” Instead, it gives us a snapshot of what’s happening in our lives right now and then suggests the probable outcome if those forces continue moving in the same direction.

To use a very simple example, suppose you get the Two of Cups—falling in love—followed by the Three of Swords—heartbreak.

That might suggest that the new romance you’re entering isn’t likely to work out. But that’s not written in stone, because nothing is written in stone. The cards are essentially saying:

“This is where things appear to be heading if nothing changes.”

And nothing changing is one reason certain cards may constantly reappear. If we’re stuck in a loop in which we keep doing the same things over and over, the cards representing that pattern may simply keep coming back.

And here’s the deal: we’re not supposed to stay the same. Human beings are constantly learning, changing and evolving. If the Tarot keeps throwing the same card at you, it may be pointing toward a pattern that needs to change.

In the example above, perhaps you keep falling in love with people who eventually hurt you. At some point, stop looking at them and start looking at yourself.

Why am I doing this? Why am I repeatedly attracted to people who can’t fulfill me or meet my needs?

The repeating Tarot card may not be telling you what is going to happen next. It may be telling you what you keep doing.

PEOPLE

There are times when another person exerts a particularly strong influence on our lives, and we need to be aware of what they’re doing. When that happens, the Tarot may repeatedly produce the same card to represent that person and call our attention to them.

There’s nothing particularly unusual about cards representing people. The Court Cards have traditionally served that function, but other cards can do it as well.

For instance, if you’re involved with someone who is particularly loving and nurturing, The Empress may appear prominently because she embodies those qualities.

I’ve found, though, that repeating cards representing people can become particularly noticeable when there’s conflict involved—when someone else’s actions may be affecting you in ways you need to recognize.

For example, I was once involved in a contested probate, and the Queen of Pentacles reversed kept appearing.

In another context, the reversed Queen of Pentacles might suggest a need for self-nurturing, insecurity around material matters, or energies that have become overly focused on possessions and control.

But when she represents another person, the interpretation can be quite different. As Sasha Fenton rather memorably puts it:

“This lady will win if involved in a fight with the questioner, especially if money is involved.”

That was certainly an interesting card to have repeatedly appearing during a legal dispute over an estate. To me, the message was clear: pay attention to this person. Don’t underestimate her. Money and material interests are central to what’s happening.

So when one card keeps popping up—particularly during a troubled or stressful period—ask yourself:

Could this card represent someone in my life? Is the Tarot pointing a great big flashing neon arrow at someone and saying:

“Pay attention to this one.”

DENIAL

Human beings can go to amazing lengths to avoid seeing something when we really don’t want to see it.

Psychologist Jennifer Freyd coined the term “betrayal blindness” to describe the way people may remain unaware of, or fail to fully acknowledge, betrayal when it threatens an important relationship or situation.

Imagine, for example, a woman whose husband is cheating on her.

The evidence may be sitting right there in plain sight: unexplained motel receipts, long private phone calls, suspicious messages on social media. But somehow she doesn’t put the pieces together.

Then one day something happens and suddenly everything clicks and she asks “How could I have been so blind?”

As the old cliché puts it: “Denial ain’t a river in Egypt.”

And Tarot doesn’t seem to have much patience with denial. If there’s something in your life that is vitally important for you to acknowledge and deal with, the cards may keep pointing toward it over and over again until you’re finally willing to look.

In the situation we just described, perhaps the Seven of Swords—traditionally associated with secrecy, deception and things happening behind the scenes—keeps appearing.

At first, the woman may be genuinely puzzled. “What in the world does that have to do with me?”

But the card keeps coming back.

Seven of Swords.

Seven of Swords.

Seven of Swords.

Eventually, instead of asking what the card means, she begins asking a much more useful question: “What am I not seeing?”

And that’s when she may finally start noticing those motel receipts.

TAKE THE BLINDERS OFF

If we wanted to sum all of this up in one sentence, it might simply be: Take the blinders off.

Or perhaps: take off the rose-colored glasses.

When the Tarot repeatedly gives us the same card, the most useful response isn’t necessarily to reshuffle the deck and ask the question again.

It’s to stop. Look at the card.

And ask yourself: Why does this particular message keep coming back?

Am I stuck in a pattern? Does this card represent someone who is having an important influence on my life? Is there something happening that I don’t want to acknowledge?

Sometimes the card that won’t go away is precisely the card we most need to understand.

Tarot can be remarkably patient. It can whisper the same message very gently for a very long time. But it can also be remarkably persistent.

At a certain point, you have a choice: deal with the issue—or quit asking the cards about it.

What you can’t do is keep asking the same question and expect the Tarot to tell you something different.