The Page of Cups: Synchronicity and the Fish in Your Wine

Why is there a fish in the Page of Cups? Explore this Tarot card’s surprising connection to synchronicity, intuition, unexpected guidance, and finding a new way forward.

Page of Cups from the Rider-Waite-Smith Tarot

The Page of Cups has a rather glaring message right on the face of it, and yet it’s one we frequently miss.

There’s a fish in the cup.

Um . . . what?

Pardon me, waiter, but there seems to be a fish in my wine.

It’s one of those elements that so completely doesn’t belong in the picture that we frequently fail to notice it. It shouldn’t be there, so our brains simply don’t register it.

What in the hell is this all about?

In Tarot, the Pages generally represent beginnings, learning, curiosity, discovery, and the emergence of new possibilities. They’re the youngest members of the court cards, and their energy is exploratory rather than authoritative.

The Page of Cups, in particular, represents emotional openness, imagination, intuition, sensitivity, and the awakening of spiritual or artistic gifts. It’s frequently associated with dreams, psychic impressions, and unexpected intuitive discoveries.

And I would suggest that the fish in the cup represents that last quality: unexpected intuitive discoveries.

We have a word for that: synchronicity.

I’ve written extensively about synchronicity in the past (see Finding Meaning With Synchronicity), but just to recap, synchronicity occurs when two or more events are meaningfully connected without any apparent relationship of cause and effect.

The classic example is thinking about a friend you haven’t seen or spoken to in twenty years. Suddenly, the phone rings and — shazam! — it’s your friend.

There’s no obvious reason why your long-lost friend should call at precisely the moment you’re thinking about her. And yet, there it is.

Like a fish in a cup.

Synchronicity shouldn’t be there, but it is.

Sometimes We Need a Fish in Our Cup

There’s a familiar saying, frequently misattributed to Albert Einstein, that insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.

Unfortunately, that seems to describe an increasing number of people’s lives.

They get up every morning, work their asses off, and somehow never get ahead. There are always more bills and less money. More obligations and less time.

We’ve invented all sorts of metaphors for this predicament. We’re on a treadmill. We’re running on a hamster wheel. We’re stuck in a rut.

It isn’t that people aren’t working hard. It’s that all that hard work isn’t getting them anywhere. And when they continue to get nowhere, they throw themselves into even more work. Some people are working two or three jobs just to break even.

The problem isn’t necessarily a lack of effort. Sometimes it’s the entire approach.

What they need is something completely different. Something they’ve never been taught, never considered, perhaps never even imagined.

They need a fish in their cup.

Free illustrated Tarot ebook

The Process of Synchronicity

I would suggest that there are three important steps in opening ourselves to the possibility of synchronicity bringing meaningful change into our lives.

The first is recognizing that what we’re doing isn’t working.

This can be considerably more difficult than it sounds because most of us have been conditioned to blame ourselves when things go wrong.

We don’t question the system. We question our own abilities.

Instead of walking away from dysfunctional patterns, we double down. We work twice as hard, try twice as many things, and keep hoping that somehow all this additional effort will finally produce the results we want.

Sometimes, however, the answer isn’t to work harder. It’s to stop doing what doesn’t work.

The second step is asking for help.

This involves sitting our asses down, getting quiet, and turning the problem over to the Universe. Or our guides, angels, gods, goddesses, higher selves — whatever language works for you.

It’s saying something like:

“You know what? My life isn’t working out the way I want it to. I’ve racked my brain trying to find solutions, and nothing seems to work. Could you give me a hand here?”

That’s it. No elaborate ritual required.

The third step is moving into receiving mode.

You’ve made your request. Now you need to be receptive to the answer.

And this can be really, REALLY difficult.

For one thing, it involves letting go of control. For another, it means being willing to consider something you’ve never considered before.

Letting go of control runs counter to almost everything we’ve been taught since childhood.

We’ve been conditioned to believe that success is a function of intelligence, planning, and hard work. If there’s a problem, we need to analyze it, figure out a solution, and get busy implementing it.

Consequently, even as we’re admitting that our approach isn’t working, our busy little brains are going into overdrive trying to figure out what to do next.

But if we’re constantly supplying our own answers, how are we going to recognize an answer that comes from somewhere unexpected?

Have you ever had a friend who repeatedly comes to you for advice, but no matter what you suggest, they immediately explain why it won’t work?

There’s a rather wonderful term for that person: an ask-hole.

They ask for help, but they aren’t really interested in hearing the answers.

And sometimes we do exactly the same thing with the Universe.

We ask for guidance, then immediately start filling in the blanks ourselves.

We’re asking, but we’re not listening.

Tarot and the Art of Alignment book

Being Open to Something Completely New

This may be the most challenging part of the entire process because genuine change can conflict with the identities we’ve spent years constructing.

Suppose you’ve devoted your adult life to becoming an electrical engineer.

And you’re good at it. People hire you, you make a comfortable living, and you’ve got a nice place to live.

But somehow, you’re never really happy.

Way back when you were a kid, before you invested all that time and education in doing the sensible thing, you had a fantasy about living on a little farm in the mountains and raising goats.

Of course, that was ridiculous. You couldn’t make a decent living raising goats. So you put the dream aside, went to college, and became an electrical engineer.

Now, years later, you sit down and say:

“Universe, I’m really not happy. In fact, I feel pretty miserable most of the time. What should I do?”

The next morning, you go to your post office box and discover a misdelivered catalog of farm equipment.

You come out of the post office and there’s a Ram truck parked next to your car.

You drive to work, finish a particularly difficult project, and someone congratulates you by calling you the Greatest Of All Time.

That evening, you go to a restaurant and discover goat cheese and goat milk on the menu.

Goats, goats, goats.

Not exactly subtle, right?

And in my experience, synchronicity frequently ISN’T subtle.

Nonetheless, there’s a very good chance you’ll ignore all those signs.

Why?

Because you’re an electrical engineer.

You’ve spent years building a professional identity, and being a goat farmer simply doesn’t fit into the picture.

Besides, you’re a rational person. You know perfectly well that a Ram truck is just a truck, GOAT is just an acronym, and somebody at the post office made a mistake.

And, of course, you’re right.

Each event has a perfectly ordinary explanation.

But the curious thing about synchronicity is that the individual events can be perfectly ordinary while their apparent connection is extraordinary.

The question isn’t necessarily whether the Universe is literally sending you messages about goats.

The question is why goats have suddenly become so meaningful to you — and whether that meaning is pointing toward something you’ve been ignoring.

Perhaps you don’t need to abandon engineering and become a goat farmer tomorrow morning.

Perhaps you simply need to acknowledge that the life you’ve constructed isn’t the life you really want.

And perhaps that acknowledgment will open the door to possibilities you haven’t yet imagined.

But first, you have to notice the fish in your cup.

Just the Tarot definitions book

The Page Is Just the Beginning

As I mentioned earlier, the Pages represent beginnings.

And that’s what I think the Page of Cups is telling us about synchronicity.

It’s the beginning of a process, not the end.

It’s that first unexpected glimmer of awareness that perhaps there’s something fundamentally wrong with the way we’ve been approaching our lives.

Perhaps the answers aren’t going to come from working harder, thinking faster, or developing yet another elaborate plan.

Perhaps the answers will come from becoming quiet enough to recognize possibilities that have been sitting right in front of us all along.

Of course, recognizing a possibility isn’t the same thing as acting on it.

We still have to acknowledge what isn’t working, ask for help, remain receptive, and be willing to follow where our discoveries lead.

But that doesn’t necessarily mean more struggle.

In fact, one of the most appealing aspects of synchronicity is that it often seems to work in precisely the opposite way.

Instead of forcing events into place, we begin noticing opportunities, connections, and possibilities that seem to emerge naturally.

Instead of constantly pushing against life, we begin moving with it.

And sometimes, the whole process begins with something so completely unexpected that we almost overlook it.

Like a fish in a cup.

Unknown's avatar

Author: Dan Adair

Artist, writer, semi-retired wizard, and the author of, "Just the Tarot," by Dan Adair

Leave a Reply